Then I started on the filling. I was blending lemon peel and sugar together when I noticed it looked like a larger amount than usual. I measured it out and it came to 1 2/3 cup. It should have been 1 1/4 cup. Not sure where that extra 5/12 of a cup came from. I dumped the extra sugar out, but that also meant I dumped out the lemon peel, so it definitely wasn't going to taste as lemony as it could.
I finished the filling, poured it on the crust, and stuck it in the oven, then realized a minute later that I hadn't added the heavy cream. Mike took it out, I stirred in the cream as best I could, then put it back in the oven...at the wrong temperature. Again!! Of course, I only figured that out when I came downstairs to get it and the consistency was all eggy rather than creamy.
The next day, I left for work at 5:40 AM so that I could have time to stop at the store and get Mike a cake that didn't have the consistency of a bouncy ball. I called Mike from the store to tell him I was getting another cake because the other one was more like a thick lemon-flavored omelet. He volunteered to try it, just to make sure it was bad. He said he liked it, but I wasn't convinced he wasn't just being nice. I grabbed three mango key lime personal-sized cakes and went to pick out wrapping paper. The store had two options: pink princess sparkley wrapping paper and "You're having a baby!" wrapping paper. Urgh. They also had white butcher paper, so guess what I ended up getting.
I left work an hour and a half early with my butcher paper and little cakes so I could avoid rush hour. It was a very warm day and I came back to a hot, hot car. And then I got stuck in traffic. There were 6 accidents on the way home, and I was on the road over two hours. By the time I arrived in DuPont, the back-up cakes I had purchased were more like soup. I walked inside, looked at Mike, and instead of greeting him with a kiss, burst into tears. Mike told me that I was not allowed to cry on his birthday, but it was too late. I felt like, despite my best efforts, I'd ruined the day. Bless his heart, Mike's always such a good sport and said he was happy just to have me there, but, seriously, look at the pictures.
See? Not pretty. It looks like a jar of strawberry jam sneezed on a giant egg yolk. And this last one of Mike. His lips may be smiling, but I swear my poor husband's eyes are silently screaming.
So we ended up with the original rubbery cheesecake, part of which Mike had already eaten because he thought it wasn't going to be his birthday cake, and butcher paper-wrapped presents. I guess we can call it a Pac Man-themed party, but it wasn't exactly a high point in my career as a wife.
What Michelle doesn't tell you is that her "ruined" cheesecake was good enough to make Martha Stewart herself green with envy. If I only tried the bad version, I can only guess that I wouldn't every get to try the good version because the moment it would be finished, it would be taken to heaven for consumption there.
ReplyDeleteI can't tell you how often I feel like that with plans I make to surprise Steve. Somehow, my plans always fall through and his plans are super duper. Don't worry Michelle, I'm sure Mike appreciated everything you did for him.
ReplyDeleteCome what may and love it! (I love that quote.) Wonderful post Michelle!
ReplyDeleteMOM
Despite nearly every effort, I typically end up getting super stressed on Richard's birthdays. Even when things go pretty well. But I hear you. :/ You tried hard to do a lot for him and you love him. That's what matters. If you're still sad, you could buy a pinata and you can each tae-bo/kickbox it to death. Seriously, its fun! And I'm guessing you got the pink sparkly paper??!!! :) Happy late birthday to Mike!
ReplyDelete